Re: Separate HEAP WAL replay logic into its own file

> On Jul 23, 2024, at 09:54, Sutou Kouhei <kou(at)clear-code(dot)com> wrote:
>
>
> Here are my comments for your patch:
>
> 1. Could you create your patch by "git format-patch -vN master"
> or something? If you create your patch by "git format-patch",
> we can apply your patch by "git am XXX.patch".
>

Thanks for your review. I’ve updated the patch to follow your
suggested format.

>
> 3. Could you remove '#include "access/heapam_xlog.h"' from
> heapam.c because it's needless now.
>
> BTW, it seems that we can remove more includes from
> heapam.c:
>
> 4. Could you remove needless includes from heapam_xlog.c? It
> seems that we can remove the following includes:

I have removed the redundant includes in the latest patch.

>
> 5. There are still WAL related codes in heapam.c:
>
> 4.1. log_heap_update()
> 4.2. log_heap_new_cid()
> 4.3. if (RelationNeedsWAL()) {...} in heap_insert()
> 4.4. if (needwal) {...} in heap_multi_insert()
> 4.5. if (RelationNeedsWAL()) {...} in heap_delete()
> 4.6. if (RelationNeedsWAL()) {...}s in heap_update()
> 4.7. if (RelationNeedsWAL()) {...} in heap_lock_tuple()
> 4.8. if (RelationNeedsWAL()) {...} in heap_lock_updated_tuple_rec()
> 4.9. if (RelationNeedsWAL()) {...} in heap_finish_speculative()
> 4.10. if (RelationNeedsWAL()) {...} in heap_abort_speculative()
> 4.11. if (RelationNeedsWAL()) {...} in heap_inplace_update()
> 4.12. log_heap_visible()
>
> Should we move them to head_xlog.c too?
>
> If we should do it, separated commits will be easy to
> review. For example, the 0001 patch moves existing codes
> to head_xlog.c as-is. The 0002 patch extracts WAL related
> codes in heap_insert() to heap_xlog.c and so on.
>
>
> Thanks,
> --
> kou

I followed the convention of most access methods. The “xlog”
file includes the WAL replay logic only. The logic that generates
the log records themselves stays with the code that performs
the changes. Take nbtree as an example, you can also find
WAL generating code in several _bt_insertxxx() functions inside
the nbtinsert.c file.

Please help review the updated file again. Thanks in advance!

Yong