Aw: Re: pg_dump include/exclude data, was: verify checksums / CREATE DATABASE

> > The problem I hope to protect against with this approach: the
> > CREATE DATABASE might untaint corrupted data from a bad disk
> > block into a good disk block virtue of doing a file level
> > copy.
> >
> > I hope my reasoning isn't going astray.
>
> As I understand it checksums are done on the page level using a hash(for
> details: https://doxygen.postgresql.org/checksum__impl_8h_source.html)
> I am not sure how a page could get un-corrupted by virtue of a file copy.

Ah, no, I did not explain myself well.

Let's assume a corrupted, bad (but readable at the hardware
level) disk block B. A filesystem level copy (as in CREATE
DATABASE) would successfully read that disk block B and
copy the corrupted content into a good disk block G elsewhere
on the disk. Verifying the checksum of the page sitting on
block B before doing the database cloning would
reveal the corruption before it got cloned.

Does that make sense ?

Karsten