BUG #8396: Window function results differ when selecting from table and view, with where clause

From: paul(at)weotta(dot)com
To: pgsql-bugs(at)postgresql(dot)org
Subject: BUG #8396: Window function results differ when selecting from table and view, with where clause
Date: 2013-08-24 07:15:54
Message-ID: E1VD84g-0000yS-TU@wrigleys.postgresql.org
Views: Raw Message | Whole Thread | Download mbox | Resend email
Thread:
Lists: pgsql-bugs

The following bug has been logged on the website:

Bug reference: 8396
Logged by: Paul M.
Email address: paul(at)weotta(dot)com
PostgreSQL version: 9.3rc1
Operating system: Ubuntu Linux
Description:

When I select from a view, the where clause in my select statement does not
restrict the rows processed by window functions referenced inside the view
definition. Thus, if window functions are involved, using a where clause
when selecting from a view and using a where clause when selecting directly
from the underlying table produces different results.

Without wanting to speculate on the cause of the differing results, I will
say that this seems to be a case of an issue noted a year ago on Stack
Overflow: "Will Postgres push down a WHERE clause into a VIEW with a Window
Function (Aggregate)?"

http://stackoverflow.com/questions/7533877/

At that time, responder Evan Carroll noted, "I can't think of anyway an
un-referenced Window function can change the result if the WHERE was pushed
down." This seems to be just such a case.

Thanks in advance for looking into this. I've written a test case, which I
hope will be helpful...

create table plant (
plant_id character varying( 6 )
, city character varying( 25 )
, constraint p_pk_pid primary key ( plant_id )
);

insert into plant
( plant_id, city )
values
( '14 ST', 'San Francisco' )
, ( 'FOLSOM', 'San Francisco' )
, ( 'CHAVEZ', 'San Francisco' )
, ( 'HEINZ', 'Berkeley' )
;

create view plant_extend as
select
plant_id as plant_id
, row_number() over ( partition by city order by plant_id ) as plant_number
, count(*) over ( partition by city ) as of_plants_in_city
, city as city
from plant;

-- Despite the where clause, the window functions see all 3 San Francisco
plants:

select
*
from plant_extend
where
plant_id = 'FOLSOM'
;

-- But when the query is expressed this way, the window functions see only
the Folsom Street plant:

select
plant_id as plant_id
, row_number() over ( partition by city order by plant_id ) as plant_number
, count(*) over ( partition by city ) as of_plants_in_city
, city as city
from plant
where
plant_id = 'FOLSOM'
;

Responses

Browse pgsql-bugs by date

  From Date Subject
Next Message harukat 2013-08-24 11:46:59 BUG #8397: pg_basebackup -x from new standby server sometimes causes Segmentation fault
Previous Message Jaime Casanova 2013-08-24 06:14:28 Re: BUG #8394: SQL command REINDEX doesn't work