Re: Intermittent hangs with 9.2

On Tue, Sep 10, 2013 at 10:04 AM, David Whittaker <dave(at)iradix(dot)com> wrote:
> Hi All,
>
> I've been seeing a strange issue with our Postgres install for about a year
> now, and I was hoping someone might be able to help point me at the cause.
> At what seem like fairly random intervals Postgres will become unresponsive
> to the 3 application nodes it services. These periods tend to last for 10 -
> 15 minutes before everything rights itself and the system goes back to
> normal.
>
> During these periods the server will report a spike in the outbound
> bandwidth (from about 1mbs to about 5mbs most recently), a huge spike in
> context switches / interrupts (normal peaks are around 2k/8k respectively,
> and during these periods they‘ve gone to 15k/22k), and a load average of
> 100+. CPU usage stays relatively low, but it’s all system time reported,
> user time goes to zero. It doesn‘t seem to be disk related since we’re
> running with a shared_buffers setting of 24G, which will fit just about our
> entire database into memory, and the IO transactions reported by the server,
> as well as the disk reads reported by Postgres stay consistently low.
>
> We‘ve recently started tracking how long statements take to execute, and
> we’re seeing some really odd numbers. A simple delete by primary key, for
> example, from a table that contains about 280,000 rows, reportedly took
> 18h59m46.900s. An update by primary key in that same table was reported as
> 7d 17h 58m 30.415s. That table is frequently accessed, but obviously those
> numbers don't seem reasonable at all.
>
> Some other changes we've made to postgresql.conf:
>
> synchronous_commit = off
>
> maintenance_work_mem = 1GB
> wal_level = hot_standby
> wal_buffers = 16MB
>
> max_wal_senders = 10
>
> wal_keep_segments = 5000
>
> checkpoint_segments = 128
>
> checkpoint_timeout = 30min
>
> checkpoint_completion_target = 0.9
>
> max_connections = 500
>
> The server is a Dell Poweredge R900 with 4 Xeon E7430 processors, 48GB of
> RAM, running Cent OS 6.3.
>
> So far we‘ve tried disabling Transparent Huge Pages after I found a number
> of resources online that indicated similar interrupt/context switch issues,
> but it hasn’t resolve the problem. I managed to catch it happening once and
> run a perf which showed:
>
> + 41.40% 48154 postmaster 0x347ba9 f 0x347ba9
> + 9.55% 10956 postmaster 0x2dc820 f set_config_option
> + 8.64% 9946 postmaster 0x5a3d4 f writeListPage
> + 5.75% 6609 postmaster 0x5a2b0 f
> ginHeapTupleFastCollect
> + 2.68% 3084 postmaster 0x192483 f
> build_implied_join_equality
> + 2.61% 2990 postmaster 0x187a55 f build_paths_for_OR
> + 1.86% 2131 postmaster 0x794aa f get_collation_oid
> + 1.56% 1822 postmaster 0x5a67e f ginHeapTupleFastInsert
> + 1.53% 1766 postmaster 0x1929bc f
> distribute_qual_to_rels
> + 1.33% 1558 postmaster 0x249671 f cmp_numerics
>
> I‘m not sure what 0x347ba9 represents, or why it’s an address rather than a
> method name.
>
> That's about the sum of it. Any help would be greatly appreciated and if you
> want any more information about our setup, please feel free to ask.

Reducing shared buffers to around 2gb will probably make the problem go away

*) What's your ratio reads to writes (approximately)?

*) How many connections when it happens. Do connections pile on after that?

*) Are you willing to run custom patched postmaster to help
troubleshoot the problem?

merlin