Re: increasing the default WAL segment size

On Thu, Aug 25, 2016 at 1:04 AM, Wolfgang Wilhelm
<wolfgang20121964(at)yahoo(dot)de> wrote:
> What would happen if there's a database on a server with initdb (or
> whatever) parameter -with-wal-size=64MB and later someone decides to make it
> the master in a replicated system and has a slave without that parameter?
> Would the slave work with the "different" wal size of the master? How could
> be guaranteed that in such a scenario the replication either works correctly
> or failes with a meaningful error message?

You make reference to an "initdb (or whatever) parameter" but actually
there is a big difference between the "initdb" case and the "whatever"
case. If the parameter is fixed at initdb time, then the master and
the slave will definitely agree: the slave had to be created by
copying the master, and that means the control file that contains the
size was also copied. Neither can have been changed afterwards.
That's what an initdb-time parameter means. On the other hand, if the
parameter is, say, a GUC, then you would have exactly the kinds of
problems that you are talking about here. I am not keen to solve any
of those problems, which is why I am not proposing to go any further
than an initdb-time parameter.

> But in general I thing a more flexible WAL size is a good idea.
> To answer Andres: You have found one of the (few?) users to adjust initdb
> parameters.

Good to know, thanks.

In further defense of the idea that making this more configurable
isn't nuts, it's worth noting that the history here is:

* When Vadim originally added XLogSegSize in
30659d43eb73272e20f2eb1d785a07ba3b553ed8 (September 1999), it was a
constant.
* In c3c09be34b6b0d7892f1087a23fc6eb93f3c4f04 (February 2004), this
became configurable via pg_config_manual.h.
* In cf9f6c8d8e9df28f3fbe1850ca7f042b2c01252e (May 2008), Tom made
this configurable via configure.

So there's a well-established history of making this gradually easier
for users to change.

--
Robert Haas
EnterpriseDB: http://www.enterprisedb.com
The Enterprise PostgreSQL Company