Outer joins?

From: Emils <gnudiff(at)gmail(dot)com>
To: pgsql-sql(at)postgresql(dot)org
Subject: Outer joins?
Date: 2006-04-28 13:23:53
Message-ID: 9dcb6fa40604280623h6f353153y@mail.gmail.com
Views: Raw Message | Whole Thread | Download mbox | Resend email
Thread:
Lists: pgsql-sql

Hello!

I am a longtime postgres user (started around 10 years ago), however,
as for some years I've been using it mostly as administrator.

Now that I have started a project and doing some SQL, I've come up
something I don't believe is right. Maybe I am too rusty on my SQL -
if so, please forgive me, but I checked it and my reasoning seemed ok
to me.

I am trying to do simple self-joins.

The table structure is:

object_values
==========
obj_id
att_id
value

namely, each object can have arbitrary number of attributes each of
them with a value.

What I want, is a simple table of objects with some of their specific
attributes, the result should be in form:

obj_id1 o1att1_value o1att2_value o1att3_value
obj_id2 o2att1_value o2att2_value o2att3_value
...

Obviously, if eg obj2 doesn't have att2 in the table, I want a NULL in
that grid point.

So, I thought some nested outer joins should be OK?

SELECT
OV.obj_id AS obj_id,
OV.value AS NAME,
ov1.value AS DESCRIPTION,
ov2.value AS ICON
FROM
object_values OV LEFT JOIN object_values ov1 USING(obj_id)
LEFT JOIN object_values ov2 USING(obj_id)
WHERE OV.att_id=7 AND ov1.att_id=8 AND ov2.att_id=16;

So, I figured this should get me all objects that have atttribute 7
defined, regardless of whether the other attributes exist for them?

However, for some reason PG8.1 is giving me something like an INNER
join on this query - namely ONLY rows where ALL the attributes ARE
present.

Am I doing something wrong? As I said my SQL is rusty, but this looked
pretty straightforward to me...

Thanks in advance,
Emils

Responses

Browse pgsql-sql by date

  From Date Subject
Next Message Stephan Szabo 2006-04-28 13:46:06 Re: Outer joins?
Previous Message Alexis Paul Bertolini 2006-04-28 10:58:55 Re: set return function is returning a single record, multiple