Unexpected Results from regexp_replace

From: Susan Hurst <susan(dot)hurst(at)brookhurstdata(dot)com>
To: pgsql-general(at)postgresql(dot)org
Subject: Unexpected Results from regexp_replace
Date: 2015-11-10 20:12:09
Message-ID: 3bc24f543d53abb1ac4f010bb9ac45f3@mail.brookhurstdata.net
Views: Raw Message | Whole Thread | Download mbox | Resend email
Thread:
Lists: pgsql-general

I would like to extract only letters and numbers [0-9a-z] from an input
string. Using regexp_replace in postgres, I get unexpected results.
The pattern matching seems to stop before the end of the string value is
reached. Some of the values that should have been excluded are still
there. What is the trick for removing all instances of unwanted
characters and spaces? I tried regexp_matches but the results were no
better.

In Oracle, the same code produces the expected results. Below is the
code and the output from postgres and from oracle, for your reference.
Thanks for your help!

Sue

-----------------------------------------------------------------------
POSTGRESQL: Incorrect results...left over unwanted characters
create table test_str (greeting varchar(256),v_greeting varchar(256));

select * from test_str;

insert into test_str (greeting) values ('Hello Worldy');
insert into test_str (greeting) values ('Hello, World!');
insert into test_str (greeting) values ('hello_world');
insert into test_str (greeting) values ('Hello! World.');
insert into test_str (greeting) values ('hello - world');
insert into test_str (greeting) values ('hello_world n');
insert into test_str (greeting) values ('hello world n n');

select greeting,regexp_replace (lower(greeting),'[^0-9a-z]{1,}','') str
from test_str
;

greeting str
Hello Worldy helloworldy
Hello, World! helloworld!
hello_world helloworld
Hello! World. helloworld.
hello - world helloworld
hello_world n helloworld n
hello world n n helloworld n n

------------------------------------------------------------------------
ORACLE: Correct results...all unwanted characters are gone
create table test_str (greeting varchar2(256),v_greeting varchar2(256));

select * from test_str;

insert into test_str (greeting) values ('Hello Worldy');
insert into test_str (greeting) values ('Hello, World!');
insert into test_str (greeting) values ('hello_world');
insert into test_str (greeting) values ('Hello! World.');
insert into test_str (greeting) values ('hello - world');
insert into test_str (greeting) values ('hello_world n');
insert into test_str (greeting) values ('hello world n n');

select greeting,regexp_replace (lower(greeting),'[^0-9a-z]{1,}','') str
from test_str
;
GREETING STR
Hello Worldy helloworldy
Hello, World! helloworld
hello_world helloworld
Hello! World. helloworld
hello - world helloworld
hello_world n helloworldn
hello world n n helloworldnn

--
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Susan E Hurst
Principal Consultant
Email: susan(dot)hurst(at)brookhurstdata(dot)com
Mobile: 314-486-3261

Responses

Browse pgsql-general by date

  From Date Subject
Next Message David G. Johnston 2015-11-10 20:19:10 Re: Unexpected Results from regexp_replace
Previous Message Adrian Klaver 2015-11-10 19:16:20 Re: Best tool to pull from mssql