advice sought - general approaches to optimizing queries around "event streams"

From: Jonathan Vanasco <postgres(at)2xlp(dot)com>
To: PostgreSQL general <pgsql-general(at)postgresql(dot)org>
Subject: advice sought - general approaches to optimizing queries around "event streams"
Date: 2014-09-26 21:02:25
Message-ID: 23BD7FFD-FB8F-40CF-B569-B5530BCEDA06@2xlp.com
Views: Raw Message | Whole Thread | Download mbox | Resend email
Thread:
Lists: pgsql-general


I have a growing database with millions of rows that track resources against an event stream.

i have a few handfuls of queries that interact with this stream in a variety of ways, and I have managed to drop things down from 70s to 3.5s on full scans and offer .05s partial scans.

no matter how i restructure queries, I can't seem to get around a few bottlenecks and I wanted to know if there were any tips/tricks from the community on how to approach them.

a simple form of my database would be:

-- 1k of
create table stream (
id int not null primary key,
)

-- 1MM of
create table resource (
id int not null primary key,
col_a bool,
col_b bool,
col_c text,
);

-- 10MM of
create table streamevent (
id int not null,
event_timestamp timestamp not null,
stream_id int not null references stream(id)
);

-- 10MM of
create table resource_2_stream_event(
resource_id int not null references resource(id),
streamevent_id int not null references streamevent(id)
)

Everything is running off of indexes; there are no seq scans.

I've managed to optimize my queries by avoiding joins against tables, and turning the stream interaction into a subquery or CTE.
better performance has come from limiting the number of "stream events" ( which are only the timestamp and resource_id off a joined table )

The bottlenecks I've encountered have primarily been:

1. When interacting with a stream, the ordering of event_timestamp and deduplicating of resources becomes an issue.
I've figured out a novel way to work with the most recent events, but distant events are troublesome

using no limit, the query takes 3500 ms
using a limit of 10000, the query takes 320ms
using a limit of 1000, the query takes 20ms

there is a dedicated index of on event_timestamp (desc) , and it is being used
according to the planner... finding all the records is fine; merging-into and sorting the aggregate to handle the deduplication of records in a stream seems to be the issue (either with DISTINCT or max+group_by)

2. I can't figure out an effective way to search for a term against an entire stream (using a tsquery/gin based search)

I thought about limiting the query by finding matching resources first, then locking it to an event stream, but:
- scanning the entire table for a term takes about 10 seconds on an initial hit. subsequent queries for the same terms end up using the cache, and complete within 20ms.

I get better search performance by calculating the event stream, then searching it for matching documents, but I still have the performance issues related to limiting the window of events

i didn't include example queries, because I'm more concerned with the general approaches and ideas behind dealing with large data sets than i am with raw SQL right now.

i'm hoping someone can enlighten me into looking at new ways to solve these problems. i think i've learned more about postgres/sql in the past 48hour than I have in the past 15 years, and I'm pretty sure that the improvements I need will come from new ways of querying data , rather than optimizing the current queries.

Responses

Browse pgsql-general by date

  From Date Subject
Next Message Brent Wood 2014-09-26 21:22:34 Re: advice sought - general approaches to optimizing queries around "event streams"
Previous Message Bosco Rama 2014-09-26 20:24:59 Re: password in recovery.conf