Re: io storm on checkpoints, postgresql 8.2.4, linux

On Wed, Aug 22, 2007 at 07:33:35PM +0400, Dmitry Potapov wrote:
> Hello!
>
> We run a large (~66Gb) web-backend database on Postgresql 8.2.4 on
> Linux. The hardware is Dual Xeon 5130 with 16Gb ram, LSI Megaraid U320-2x
> scsi controller w/512Mb writeback cache and a BBU. Storage setup contains 3
> raid10 arrays (data, xlog, indexes, each on different array), 12 HDDs total.
> Frontend application uses jdbc driver, connection pooling and threads.
>
> We've run into an issue of IO storms on checkpoints. Once in 20min
> (which is checkpoint_interval) the database becomes unresponsive for about
> 4-8 seconds. Query processing is suspended, server does nothing but writing
> a large amount of data to disks. Because of the db server being stalled,
> some of the web clients get timeout and disconnect, which is unacceptable.
> Even worse, as the new requests come at a pretty constant rate, by the time
> this storm comes to an end there is a huge amount of sleeping app. threads
> waiting for their queries to complete. After the db server comes back to
> life again, these threads wake up and flood it with queries, so performance
> suffer even more, for some minutes after the checkpoint.
>
> It seemed strange to me that our 70%-read db generates so much dirty
> pages that writing them out takes 4-8 seconds and grabs the full bandwidth.
> First, I started to tune bgwriter to a more aggressive settings, but this
> was of no help, nearly no performance changes at all. Digging into the issue
> further, I discovered that linux page cache was the reason. "Dirty"
> parameter in /proc/meminfo (which shows the amount of ready-to-write "dirty"
> data currently sitting in page cache) grows between checkpoints from 0 to
> about 100Mb. When checkpoint comes, all the 100mb got flushed out to disk,
> effectively causing a IO storm.
>
> I found this (http://www.westnet.com/~gsmith/content/linux-pdflush.htm
> <http://www.westnet.com/%7Egsmith/content/linux-pdflush.htm>) document and
> peeked into mm/page-writeback.c in linux kernel source tree. I'm not sure
> that I understand pdflush writeout semantics correctly, but looks like when
> the amount of "dirty" data is less than dirty_background_ratio*RAM/100,
> pdflush only writes pages in background, waking up every
> dirty_writeback_centisecs and writing no more than 1024 pages
> (MAX_WRITEBACK_PAGES constant). When we hit dirty_background_ratio, pdflush
> starts to write out more agressively.
>
> So, looks like the following scenario takes place: postgresql constantly
> writes something to database and xlog files, dirty data gets to the page
> cache, and then slowly written out by pdflush. When postgres generates more
> dirty pages than pdflush writes out, the amount of dirty data in the
> pagecache is growing. When we're at checkpoint, postgres does fsync() on the
> database files, and sleeps until the whole page cache is written out.
>
> By default, dirty_background_ratio is 2%, which is about 328Mb of 16Gb
> total. Following the curring pdflush logic, nearly this amount of data we
> face to write out on checkpoint effective stalling everything else, so even
> 1% of 16Gb is too much. My setup experience 4-8 sec pause in operation even
> on ~100Mb dirty pagecache...
>
> I temporaly solved this problem by setting dirty_background_ratio to
> 0%. This causes the dirty data to be written out immediately. It is ok for
> our setup (mostly because of large controller cache), but it doesn't looks
> to me as an elegant solution. Is there some other way to fix this issue
> without disabling pagecache and the IO smoothing it was designed to perform?
>
> --
> Regards,
> Dmitry

Dmitry,

You are working at the correct level. The bgwriter performs the I/O smoothing
function at the database level. Obviously, the OS level smoothing function
needed to be tuned and you have done that within the parameters of the OS.
You may want to bring this up on the Linux kernel lists and see if they have
any ideas.

Good luck,

Ken