Re: [NOVICE] Question on TRUNCATE privleges

On Tue, 2005-02-22 at 14:00, Tom Lane wrote:
> "Keith Worthington" <keithw(at)narrowpathinc(dot)com> writes:
> > I have just discovered that I can speed up one of my functions by a factor of
> > 600 by changing an unqualified DELETE to a TRUNCATE. Unfortunately, the
> > function is run by multiple users and I get the error message
> > "TESTDB=> TRUNCATE inventory.tbl_item;
> > ERROR: must be owner of relation tbl_item
>
> > There is nothing in the documentation
> > (http://www.postgresql.org/docs/8.0/interactive/sql-truncate.html) about this
> > restriction ( You see Michael I am still reading the documentation. ;-) ) Do
> > I get to post my first user comment on the documentation pages? Do I? Hunh?
> > Can I? :-)
>
> Yup ;-)
>
> > Is there a way to have multiple owners of a table or otherwise achive this
> > behavior?
>
> I'm not entirely sure that requiring ownership of the table is the
> appropriate restriction for TRUNCATE. It made some sense back when
> TRUNCATE wasn't transaction-safe, but now that it is, you could almost
> argue that ordinary DELETE privilege should allow TRUNCATE.
>
> Almost. The hole in the argument is that TRUNCATE doesn't run ON DELETE
> triggers and so it could possibly be used to bypass things the table
> owner wants to have happen. You could equate TRUNCATE to DROP TRIGGER(s),
> DELETE, CREATE TRIGGER(s) ... but DROP TRIGGER requires ownership.
>
> CREATE TRIGGER only requires TRIGGER privilege which is grantable.
> So one answer is to change DROP TRIGGER to require TRIGGER privilege
> (which would mean user A could remove a trigger installed by user B,
> if both have TRIGGER privileges on the table) and then say you can
> TRUNCATE if you have both DELETE and TRIGGER privileges.
>
> It looks to me like the asymmetry between CREATE TRIGGER and DROP
> TRIGGER is actually required by SQL99, though, so changing it would
> be a hard sell (unless SQL2003 fixes it?).
>
> Comments anyone?

Isn't this a case for a SECURITY DEFINER function?

Robert Treat
--
Build A Brighter Lamp :: Linux Apache {middleware} PostgreSQL