Re: proposal: possibility to read dumped table's name from file

Hi

I am sending version with handy written parser and meson support

po 3. 10. 2022 v 6:34 odesílatel Julien Rouhaud <rjuju123(at)gmail(dot)com> napsal:

> Hi,
>
> > You started rewriting it, but you didn't finish it.
> >
> > Unfortunately, there is not a clean opinion on using bison's parser for
> > this purpose. I understand that the complexity of this language is too
> low,
> > so the benefit of using bison's gramatic is low too. Personally, I have
> not
> > any problem using bison for this purpose. For this case, I think we
> compare
> > two similarly long ways, but unfortunately, customers that have a problem
> > with long command lines still have this problem.
> >
> > Can we go forward? Daniel is strongly against handwritten parser. Is
> there
> > somebody strongly against bison's based parser? There is not any other
> way.
>
> I don't have a strong opinion either, but it seems that 2 people argued
> against
> a bison parser (vs only 1 arguing for) and the fact that the current habit
> is
> to rely on hand written parsers for simple cases (e.g. jsonapi.c /
> pg_parse_json()), it seems that we should go back to Pavel's original
> parser.
>
> I only had a quick look but it indeed seems trivial, it just maybe need a
> bit
> of refactoring to avoid some code duplication (getFiltersFromFile is
> duplicated, and getDatabaseExcludeFiltersFromFile could be removed if
> getFiltersFromFile knew about the 2 patterns).
>

I checked this code again, and I don't think some refactoring is easy.
getFiltersFromFile is not duplicated. It is just probably badly named.

These routines are used from pg_dump, pg_dumpall and pg_restore. There are
significant differences in supported objects and in types used for returned
lists (dumpOptions, SimpleStringList, and RestoreOptions). If I have one
routine, then I need to implement some mechanism for specification of
supported objects, and a special type that can be used as a proxy between
caller and parser to hold lists of parsed values. To be names less
confusing I renamed them to read_dump_filters, read_dumpall_filters and
read_restore_filters

Regards

Pavel