Strange result with "SELECT ... ORDER BY random() LIMIT 1" and JOINs

From: Etienne Dube <etdube(at)gmail(dot)com>
To: pgsql-general(at)postgresql(dot)org
Subject: Strange result with "SELECT ... ORDER BY random() LIMIT 1" and JOINs
Date: 2013-08-15 18:46:54
Message-ID: 520D221E.2060008@gmail.com
Views: Raw Message | Whole Thread | Download mbox | Resend email
Thread:
Lists: pgsql-general

Hello,

Consider the following tables and data:

----------------------------------------
CREATE TABLE color (
color_id integer PRIMARY KEY,
color_name text
);

INSERT INTO color (color_id, color_name)
VALUES
(1, 'red'),
(2, 'blue'),
(3, 'green'),
(4, 'yellow'),
(5, 'grey'),
(6, 'brown'),
(7, 'black'),
(8, 'white'),
(9, 'white with wooden panels')
;

CREATE TABLE car (
car_id integer PRIMARY KEY,
car_name text
);

INSERT INTO car (car_id, car_name)
VALUES
(1, 'Toyota Matrix'),
(2, 'Mazda 3'),
(3, 'Honda Fit'),
(4, 'Ford F-150'),
(5, 'Chevrolet Volt'),
(6, 'Audi A4'),
(7, 'Hyundai Elantra'),
(8, 'Nissan Versa'),
(9, 'Buick Estate Wagon')
;
----------------------------------------

This query yields unexpected results (tested under 9.2.4):

SELECT
s.car_id,
s.color_id AS subquery_color_id,
co.color_id AS join_color_id,
co.color_name
FROM
(
SELECT
ca.car_id,
(
SELECT color_id
FROM color
WHERE ca.car_id = ca.car_id -- dependency added to
avoid getting the same value for every row in the output
ORDER BY random()
LIMIT 1
) AS color_id
FROM
car ca
) s
LEFT JOIN color co ON co.color_id = s.color_id;

We can see the equality defined in the LEFT JOIN does not hold true for
the subquery_color_id and join_color_id column aliases in the output.
EXPLAIN also shows that the subplan for the inner subquery used to pick
a random row from the color table appears twice.

I don't really understand what is going on there, the result appears
incorrect to me. The following page seems to offer some explanations as
to what is happening:
http://sql-info.de/postgresql/postgres-gotchas.html#1_6 . Indeed, adding
OFFSET 0 to the "s" subquery solves the issue.

Can somebody shed some light on this topic? Is this behaviour correct or
should it be considered a bug?

Thanks!
Etienne

Responses

Browse pgsql-general by date

  From Date Subject
Next Message Lonni J Friedman 2013-08-15 18:51:27 Re: Streaming Replication Randomly Locking Up
Previous Message Andrew Berman 2013-08-15 18:45:42 Re: Streaming Replication Randomly Locking Up